What a NAS is for
A NAS (network attached storage) is a small computer whose job is to hold your files and share them over the network. The decision comes down to how much you want to tinker, how much storage you need, and how seriously you take backups. The last one is the one to get right.
Off the shelf or DIY
Off the shelf units from makers such as Synology, QNAP and UGREEN arrive as a complete box with an operating system, a management app and a support route. You add drives and set it up in an afternoon.
- Strengths: easy, low power, compact, good apps for photos, backups and file sharing, and a maker who updates the software.
- Limits: you pay for the software and the case. The processor is fixed and memory upgrades are limited. Some makers restrict which drives are supported, so check the compatibility list before buying drives.
DIY means building a machine from parts and installing a NAS operating system such as TrueNAS or Unraid, or a general Linux server.
- Strengths: you choose the hardware, so you can have more bays, a faster network card, ECC memory, or a stronger processor for virtual machines. You are not tied to one maker.
- Limits: you are the support desk. Parts must be chosen with care, power draw can be higher, and a setup mistake can cost data.
Rule of thumb: choose off the shelf if the NAS is an appliance you want to forget about. Choose DIY if you want to learn, need unusual hardware, or want to run many services on the same box. Our guide to NAS or DIY server goes further.
How many bays
Bays are the drive slots. Plan for growth.
- 2 bays: a mirror, or two separate disks. Cheap and small, and the first thing people outgrow.
- 4 bays: the most common home size, enough for a sensible redundant array.
- 6 to 8 bays: bigger collections and more redundancy.
- 12 and above: rack or tower storage servers.
Buy a bay or two more than you need today, because adding bays later usually means a new box. Check the drive sizes it supports, and whether it takes M.2 SSDs for cache as well as 3.5 inch drives. Compare current NAS prices by bays, memory and network speed.
RAID levels, and what they do not protect
RAID spreads data across drives to survive a drive failure or to go faster. The levels you will meet:
- RAID 0: stripes data for speed and capacity. No redundancy: one drive fails and everything is lost.
- RAID 1: a mirror of two drives. One can fail. You get the space of one drive.
- RAID 5: at least three drives, survives one failure, and you lose one drive's worth of space. Rebuilds on large drives take a long time and stress the remaining disks.
- RAID 6: at least four drives, survives two failures, and you lose two drives' worth. Safer for big arrays and big drives.
- RAID 10: a stripe of mirrors. Fast and resilient, but you lose half the raw space.
Some systems have their own equivalents, such as SHR on Synology or RAID-Z on ZFS, built on the same ideas with slightly different rules.
RAID does not protect against:
- Deleting a file by accident: the array copies the mistake.
- Ransomware or a bad sync: the array keeps the damaged copy.
- Controller, power or software faults that corrupt the whole array.
- Fire, flood and theft: one box is one copy in one place.
- A second failure during a rebuild, which on RAID 5 loses the lot.
Careful: RAID is availability, not backup. A backup is a separate copy on a separate device, ideally somewhere else. The 3-2-1 rule is a good start: three copies, on two kinds of storage, one off site. Snapshots help against deletion and ransomware but live on the same array, so they are not a backup either.
Choosing drives
Use drives designed for NAS use. They are rated for always-on running, cope with vibration in multi-bay boxes, and have firmware suited to RAID.
- CMR or SMR: conventional (CMR) drives suit RAID. Shingled (SMR) drives can be very slow to rebuild and some file systems, ZFS among them, handle them badly. Check the maker's specification for the recording method. Western Digital's plain Red line is SMR, while Red Plus and Red Pro are CMR.
- Workload rating and warranty: look at the stated yearly workload and the warranty length.
- Capacity: bigger drives cost less per terabyte but take longer to rebuild, and each one holds more of your data. For large arrays consider RAID 6 or equivalent.
- Batches: drives from one batch can fail at similar times, so some people buy from two shops.
- Noise and power: 7200 rpm drives are louder and warmer than 5400 rpm class ones.
- SSDs: useful as cache or for a fast pool, but check the write endurance for heavy cache use.
See current prices on hard drives and SSDs.
Do you need ECC?
ECC (error correcting code) memory detects and fixes single bit memory errors. File systems such as ZFS hold data in memory before writing it, so a memory error could end up on disk.
The honest answer: ECC is a good idea for a machine holding data you cannot replace, and it is cheap insurance on a DIY build. It is not mandatory, and plenty of home NAS units run without it for years. You need a processor and board that support it. Our guide to ECC RAM explains the types.
Network speed and power
A NAS on gigabit moves roughly 110 MB/s, plenty for one person. For several users, video editing or big backups, look for 2.5G or 10G ports and a switch that matches.
A NAS runs all day, so idle power matters. A 4-bay unit with spinning disks typically draws tens of watts, mostly from the drives. Our budget homelab guide turns watts into pounds a year.
Sensible starting points
- Simple home use: a 2 or 4 bay unit, mirrored or RAID 5, plus a separate backup drive.
- Learning or heavy services: a DIY build with ECC memory and enough bays. The server builder checks the parts fit.
- Important data: whatever the design, a backup on another device and one copy away from the house. A small UPS protects the array from power cuts.
Before you buy
- 1Decide appliance or DIY.
- 2Buy more bays than you need today.
- 3Choose a RAID level and write down what it does not cover.
- 4Plan the backup before the array.
- 5Check drives are CMR and on the maker's compatibility list.
- 6Decide on ECC, and check board support.
- 7Compare the same unit across shops, and note when each price was last read.